J: On Jun 10, 2007, at 2:35 PM,
Daniel wrote:
Hi,
Hi, Daniel! Sorry it took me so long to write back. You did get me
thinking. :)
I tried to understand apatheism but I just can't.
That's OK, it was mostly satirical. My own feelings of apatheism stem
from atheism (at least
regarding the dogmatic gods out there), and this apatheism admittedly
falls apart when I contemplate the kinds of gods that might
really
exist.
If there is a god who created you and the whole
world, doesn't it matter?
Depends on the type of god we're talking about. I'm not really
apathetic to the
philosophical notion that there
might be a god out there. But when it comes to the religious
descriptions of "common" gods emerging from our long history of
superstitious, non-critical thinking (not to mention the effects of
psilocybin mushrooms on our ancestors), I must confess I'm quite a bit
apathetic and
jaded. The major religions
don't seriously examine this topic, despite the gravely serious
attitudes their followers adopt while killing each other
over fairy tales. Their gods tend to oscillate between bearded old guys
in clouds and extra-dimensional aliens with strange, contradictory
lists of human taboos and punishments. It's these gods that I'm
uninterested in, just as I'm uninterested in Santa Claus.
Shouldn't you feel obligated to him, if he does
exist? Nevermind if he does exist or not, but is not this an important
issue?
It is like not caring whether you have a father or not, is it not?
That's a good analogy, but you should throw in the fact that this
supposed father you are talking about has remained entirely detached,
if he's still around. He's living in another country and hasn't sent
you a dime, or shown any real interest in your life. A phone call would
be nice, but the best you get is a one-way call, and you don't even
know if someone's listening on the other side. People
tell you
he cares about you, and they say he leaves signs of his love for you,
but it's all hearsay. If he's as rich and powerful as they say, he
should take the next flight over. I can see how some people might still
wonder about, believe in, or even worship such a god, but I'm
uninterested. I certainly don't feel obligated, and I don't think such
a
god should expect anything from me.
Perhaps if I became convinced in the real honest-to-goodness existence
of some mainstream religion's god, I'd be interested in him out of a
sense of survival. But I don't think I'd be sincere in my worship. I'd
certainly go through the motions and follow the rules to stay out of
hell or whatever, but only from coercion. If such a god only wanted
true worshipers who did not feel coerced, I'd be in deep trouble.
Luckily I will never face such a problem, barring some amazing and
highly unlikely evidence.
There are plenty of other kinds of gods—the impersonal
don't-ask-don't-tell gods—that are much more likely to exist (though I
have my strong doubts they exist either), but I would also feel no
obligations to these gods, because they prefer to stay out of the
picture anyway. I
am interested in contemplating the nature of
these kinds of gods, just as I am interested in contemplating other
forms of extraterrestrial life. So that is where my apatheism
disappears. Unfortunately (for me) most people are more interested in
discussing the bearded guy in the clouds rather than the more plausible
(to me) extra-dimensional alien sans any list of demands. I reserve
apatheism for these situations.
Searching for the creator of this universe (whether it be intelligent
or not) sounds great, and I'm not apathetic toward that search.
Seriously contemplating the existence of various gods of the Bible,
Koran, Rigveda, Tanakh, Principia, etc. does not sound interesting
anymore, and I'd rather leave that to others.
Thanks for your thoughts!
:-j