Keepers (28 cards)
- Captain's Hat
- Schooner
- Galleon
- Frigate
- Dinghy
- Sloop
- Treasure Map
- The Key
- Pearls
- Rubies
- Pieces of Eight
- Gold Doubloons
- Emeralds
- Diamonds
- Strongbox
- Oranges
- Limes
- Monkey
- Flintlock Pistol
- Royal Colors
- Jolly Roger
- Cannon
- Cutlass
- Keg
- Rum
- Tropical Island
- Parrot
- Gunpowder
Creepers (2 cards)
- Scurvy
- Shackles
Actions (19 cards)
- Shipwreck
- King's Ransom
- Walk the Plank!
- Mutiny!
- Rough Seas
- Draw 2 and Use 'em
- Draw 3, play 2 of them
- Everybody Gets 1
- Discard & Draw
- Exchange Keepers
- Jackpot!
- Let's Do That Again!
- Rules Reset
- Share the Wealth
- Trash Something
- Trash a New Rule
- Trade Hands
- Use What You Take
- Steal a Keeper
Surprises (4 cards)
- That Be Mine!
- Canceled Plans
- Avast! Halt!
- Veto!
Goals (25 cards)
- Royal Navy Ship
- Yo Ho Ho & a Bottle of Rum
- Privateers
- Shallow Seas
- Key Lime Pie
- Free the Prisoner!
- Keg of Rum
- Fresh Fruit
- Sword & Pistol
- Gems
- Armada
- Treasure Chest
- Treasure Ship
- Gold and Silver
- X Marks the Spot
- Munitions
- Powder Monkey
- Land Ho!
- Powder Keg
- Marooned
- The Captain's Parrot
- Run Out the Guns!
- Unlock the Box
- Pirate Ship
- Pirate Pets
New Rules (22 cards)
- Long Live the Captain!
- Plunder!
- Talk Like a Pirate
- Swap Plays For Draws
- No-Hand Bonus
- Double Agenda
- Hand Limit 4
- Hand Limit 3
- Hand Limit 2
- Hand Limit 1
- Keeper Limit 2
- Keeper Limit 4
- Keeper Limit 3
- Draw 5
- Draw 4
- Draw 3
- Draw 2
- Play 2
- Play 3
- Play 4
- Play All
- Basic Rules
This makes a total of 100 cards in the box. A rulesheet is also included.